HRT and heart disease. And the beat goes on….
[youtube=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ySaHZZhSwXE]
Hormone replacement therapy can help prevent heart disease, right?
Think again. Research has shown that use of HRT increases the risk for stroke, blood clots and heart disease. Although increased risk starts to decline within three years of stopping hormone therapy, women are still cautioned to continue rigorous prevention efforts and to see their physicians for any recommended testing.
So, are you asking yourselves why I’m writing about this if doctors know already about the link between HRT and heart disease? Well it appears that in the early 200s, and despite a marked decline in the use of HRT among women following confirmation of the risk, as many as 8% of women with existing heart disease and 14% with two or more identifiable risk factors were still prescribed hormones by their doctors. Writing in the American Journal of Public Health, investigators of a newly-published analysis said that although the reasons are unclear, women continued to receive HRT for heart risks, even though it “was never proven for this indication and ultimately found to be ineffective.”
To add insult to injury, the International Menopause Society, in concert with the European Society of Cardiology, has just issued a statement staying that hormone therapy, in limited doses, does not increase the risk of heart disease and may even decrease risk in younger women.What’s more, they are now saying that in some cases, HRT may even lower blood pressure. Conversely, they recommended that HRT should not be used in women with a history of heart attack, stroke or pulmonary embolism (blockage of one or more lung arteries).
Are you confused yet?
Some experts have questioned the results of the Women’s Health Initiative studies, which were the first to raise the flag about the dangers of HRT. Some argue that the studies looked at women who were older, i.e. 50 to 79 and not menopausal or perimenopausal. However, others have determined that both the timing (i.e. when HRT is started) and length of time on HRT can affect disease risks, as can type of hormone used.
In some respects, these confusing recommendations echo the recent controversy over mammography, in which medical experts have taken sides, some agreeing the screening is overrated and even dangerous, and others, saying that even the small numbers of lives saved make mammography worthwhile in younger women. That, however, is a post for another time.
Meanwhile, what should you do when it comes to HRT and heart disease risk?
As always, I urge women to err on the side of caution and do their due diligence: make an appointment with an informed health provider and discuss the risks and the benefits. There’s no way to make an informed decision without all the facts and information about how they apply specifically to you, your family and personal medical history and your unique set of needs and symptoms. At the same time, the evidence is pretty darn strong that HRT does not protect your heart and may in fact, exacerbate other risk factors for developing a heart attack or stroke.
Is it worth it? Only you and your practitioner can decide.
Read MoreWednesday Bubble: The best medicine
I’m especially happy to write this Wednesday Bubble because it’s inspiring and makes me want to jump for joy! Or better, yet, laugh a little.
Several years ago, researchers discovered that humor therapy and anticipation of laughing or being amused (also known as mirthful laughter) positively affects immunity. In fact, findings from a series of five separate studies among healthy men demonstrated that just anticipating watching a funny video could increase beta-endorphins (hormones that elevated mood) as much as 17% and human growth hormone (which contributes to more optimal immunity) by as much as 87%. Elevated hormones levels were maintained throughout the video and as long as 12 hours after. Conversely, hormone levels did not increase in men who who did not anticipate watching a humorous video and instead, browsed magazines.
Similar results were seen in another study among healthy adult women; this time mirthful laughter was associated with significant declines in stress hormones and improvements in natural killer cells, which contribute favourably to immune function.
More recently, researchers have been examining the effects of mirthful laughter on actual disease states. Findings of a year-long study presented this past April at the Experimental Biology Conference suggest that watching a funny, 30-minute video on a daily basis may impart a long lasting impact on health that includes:
- Lower stress hormones (epinephrine and norepinephrine) and related stress levels
- Lower levels of inflammation that can contribute to disease
- Significant improvements in HDL cholesterol
- Significant reductions in harmful C-reactive protein levels (a protein that increase the risk for heart disease, heart attack, stroke and death)
This particular study evaluated laughter in patients with diabetes, high blood pressure and high cholesterol who were also taking medication. Notably, similar positive outcomes were not seen in patients who did not have the benefit of watching the funny video.
What can we take away from this work and what does it have to do with menopause? Actually, I’d like to ask, what doesn’t it have to do with menopause and midlife?
During the transition, women are subject to hormonal stressors that affect mood, functioning, wellbeing as well as disease risk. If there are simpler, more natural ways to improve healthy states, for example, by daily laughter, shouldn’t we reach for them? I’d rather take a dose of funny over pharma any given day.
Here’s my gift to you: laugh today. And tomorrow. And the next day. And spread the joy. Nothing like a deep belly laugh to take some of life’s challenges away.
A little laughter may just go a lot further than previously believed.
Read MoreWednesday bubble: flava flavonoid
With the acai berry craze hitting its peak, I thought it was high time to devote a post to flavonoids (compounds found in plants, fruits and beverages that have been shown to have antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties) — namely, those found in berries.
Yes, berries, This sounded a bit preposterous until I dug a bit deeper and located a current review in Maturitas, suggesting that berry flavonoids might be important for long-term health in menopausal women. However, researchers still can’t define the most important details, for example:
- berry type
- preparation
- regimen
The amount of berry flavonoid that becomes available and used by the body after eating also varies by individual make up and by the different types of flavonoids.
All of these factors are critical to designing a strategy that will yield the maximum health benefit. Nevertheless, evidence from clinical studies suggests the following:
- The addition of berries to the diet can reduce the risk of heart disease by halting the inflammatory process, eliminating free radicals (which can harm the structure of cells), decreasing blood pressure, inhibiting the gathering of platelets (which can lead to clogged arteries) and increasing high density lipoproteins (HDL, good cholesterol)/ reducing low-density lipoproteins (LDL, bad cholesterol). Data points to cranberry juice, wild blueberries, bilberries, blackcurrant or strawberry puree, and chokeberry or raspberry juices.
- Cancer prevention. Note that this has been controversial since increased consumption of dietary fruits and vegetables and not just berries, have been shown to impact certain cancers such as esophogeal cancer. In the small studies that the researchers cite, cranberry juice and freeze dried black raspberry have been shown to control signaling that promotes the proliferation of cancer cells.
- Age-related declines in motor skills, learning and memory impairment, specifically, those linked to a decline in the body’s ability to fight circulating free oxygen radicals that can damage cells. Evidence for these benefits are primarily derived from animal and not human studies, and concentrate on strawberries, blueberries and cranberries.
The researchers caution that it’s impossible to define how much of a single berry or combination of berries might help in disease prevention. Hence, it’s too early to make any definitive claims about berry consumption. However, they do emphasize that to date, research supports the importance of berries as part of a healthy, balanced diet for menopausal women.
Personally, I love berries and health benefits or not, I plan to eat as much of them as I can get my hands on this summer.
Read MoreWednesday Bubble: I’ve got the blues and it’s all good!
I’ve got the blues this week; blueberries that is. And the news is all good!
Researchers at the University of Michigan at Ann Arbor are reporting that eating a diet rich in blue berries might reduce heart disease, protect against diabetes, and get rid of belly fat! Is this too good to be true? And what does this have to do with menopause anyway?
I’ve written previously on increased risk of heart disease and increased likelihood of gaining weight around the abdominal region as we age. So, if blueberries can potentially help to stave off both, that’s great news, right?
The research team studied the effect of a blueberry-enriched powder added to either a low-fat or high-fat diet in laboratory rats and compared them to rats receiving no blueberry powder. The rats were of a particular breed that are prone to weight gain and being severely overweight.
After 90 days, rats receiving the blueberry powder (which comprised 2% of their total diet) had less abdominal fat, and lower triglycerides and cholesterol levels. They also showed improvements in fasting blood glucose and insulin sensitivity, which measures the risk for diabetes and heart disease (namely metabolic syndrome), respectively.
What’s more, the benefits were even greater among rats fed the powder along with a low-fat diet: they had lower body weight, lower total fat mass, and reduced liver mass (which has been linked to obesity and insulin resistance) than rats in the other study groups. The researchers also reported positive changes in measures such as fat muscle tissue (which relates to fat-burning and storage) in rats fed the blueberry powder and a high-fat diet.
The beneficial effects of blueberries are believed to be possibly related to inherently high levels of an antioxidant known as anthocyanins, which is responsible for blueberries’ colour.
Clearly, further research, is needed, particularly in humans. In the interim, eat some blueberries: they’re high in flavor, a great source of fiber and vitamins C and K, and low in fat. And may help combat some of the less attractive pitfalls of mid-life.
Read MoreBad to da bone, part 2
Is there any way to prevent bone loss after menopause? It is possible that eating the proper balance of dietary fats (i.e. omega-3 fatty acids and omega-6 fatty acids) may help.
In a study published a few years ago in the Journal of Nutritional Biochemistry, researchers assessed bone mineral content and bone density in female rats. These measures are used to determine how much bone loss you have in a particular area and the risk for developing osteoporosis. The National Osteoporosis Foundation provides an excellent summary.
In the study, half the rats had their ovaries removed (leading to a rapid decline in estrogen and subsequent bone loss) and half remained intact. They were then fed diets with different ratios of omega-3s and omega-6s. After 12 weeks, data showed that rats with the lowest ratio of omega-6 to omega-3 fatty acids in their diets had significantly less bone loss and a higher bone mineral density, even in the absence of estrogen. This translated to significantly lower bone loss.
Omega-6 fatty acids are most commonly found in foods such as vegetables oils, nuts, seeds and eggs while omega-3 fatty acids are more commonly found in fatty fish (salmon, mackerel), nuts (walnuts) and certain vegetable oils. Notably, eating both omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids has been shown to lower the risk of heart and possibly other diseases. However, research continues to point to balance.
These particular findings may be due to the ability of omega-3 fatty acids to reduce the production of inflammatory compounds that associated with the breaking down or “resorption” of bones. Estrogen provides a similar protective effect but after its decline, the body becomes more vulnerable.
While researchers caution that the study results cannot be translated to humans, they certainly look promising.
It’s all about balance, right?!
Read More